The pretzels and nacho cheese are 2 stars. Supposedly it is provolone fondue but its laughable, I swear I had nacho cheese. I'm from Switzerland and we have great fondue and so does the Citizen Public House in Scottsdale. Phenomenal Fondue and bone marrow butter. We didn't finish the fondue here at the arrogant butcher, and my buddy thought it was disgusting. The New York Strip is 4 stars but I've had better. The mashed potatoes with reduced wine sauce was alright. Maybe 3.5 stars.
Now my food was a lot of mixed things. I love variety and got the butchers plate for 23 dollars. My plate with mixed cheese, sliced meat, was alright but not even close to the best. Maybe good jam and mustard and really good devilled eggs but olives and bread was below par.
People are easily satisfied and give it 5 stars. Well I guess I just had really good food before around the world to say this is not bad but I won't go again. If I go to a place and it doesn't knock me of my feet I won't go again. There are too many choices and to be successful you need to be the best or have something special. The only thing special at this place is its name. Now I know why I hate arrogant people or butchers. They think they are better than they really are. Unless you have a lot of people that just don't know better, you might have a chance, which is the case in a lot of cities.