Somewhere between a 3 and a 4 star.
Very torn on this review. Some dishes were excellent, others just average.
Service was excellent and ambience was sensational. Beautiful setting, well situated in Old Montreal, and very quaint and cozy.
Very impressed with their "20 wines under $40" - had an outstanding Syrah from California that was sensational. Also a great selection of scotches and they made an excellent Cosmopolitan.
As for the food, we rated as follows:
Scallops - sensational; worth trying
Octopus - very average - would avoid
Pasta - very good
Halibut - OUTSTANDING - great dish - try it!
Lobster - below average; not well prepared
Sorbet/Ice Cream - excellent
Overall great service, some great and some average food. Worth a try, but dont set your expectations too high.