We took my dad here for his birthday and it was atrocious. My father's dinner came with salt on the plate, under his fries and a half eaten pickle. The grilled pulled pork sandwich looked like something you could buy in the freezer section at Walmart that had been sitting under a heat lamp for a couple days. I got the turkey Reuben on potato pancakes- that was hands down the worst thing I've ever gotten. The potato pancakes were dense and had a both bland and bad taste. The turkey tasted like it was from a banquet frozen dinner. Needless to say I didn't finish it. The only edible item we received was the Bavarian nachos.
So in short, don't be fooled by the reviews or the need for reservations. If you don't want your night to revolve around the running joke of "ew who picked that place?" then you should not eat here. Very, very disappointing.