My rating isn't really set in stone. I feel like I should give Bitondo's another whirl and order a fresh pie. I ended up just popping in quickly for a slice of pepperoni, and I found it pretty average. If they had even popped it into the oven for a minute I feel like it would've been a far better experience, but unfortunately I got a tepid slice with chewy cheese. I feel like they might be able to redeem themselves to at least a 4.
Extra points for the vibe though. Very chill, kind of retro, table-top video game. Cool spot.