The atmosphere and drink options are great. I think their food menu could use some work though. We went there for dinner and they seem to have several great options but they're kind of limited in normal/boring options. I know that sounds weird but it would be nice to have a regular burger option in case you are feeling a little less adventurous that day instead of bison burgers, scallops, etc... those things are sometimes great but sometimes a person in the group just wants something normal. Again, I totally get how weird that sounds.
We also went for brunch later in the weekend with out of town guests and again, they just try too hard to be fancy. I got the Carmella's breakfast which is basically a giant breakfast with almost anything you would want. Some of those items include bacon which is over-peppered and home fry type things smothered in cheese. Bacon and home fries are already really good without trying to overdo them by smothering them in seasoning or cheese. Also, why does this meal need waffles AND toast? Most people only need one bread item for breakfast and this is overdoing it. The waffles were fine though as were the eggs. I didn't eat the sausage because I don't think anyone needs to eat sausage and bacon for breakfast and I didn't eat the huge piece of melon because I hate honeydew as do most people. If you want to serve fruit, maybe serve something a lot of people like like berries, watermelon, etc. I hate when restaurants serve honeydew/cantaloupe. I really feel like they only serve it because it's super cheap. Anyway, those are my thoughts. It wasn't horrible but it wasn't great.