I went with a flight of non-IPA drafts. Sure, some may say that I missed out on some good beers, but I would say that Ale Asylum has some pretty solid non-IPAs.
I totally suggest a flight when you are trying a brewery for the first time. Why not sample all the beers?
I think they have a good location, just have your Uber swing by to grab a beer before you fly out of Madison. It's brilliant.
The grunge vibe is warming and great for just hanging with your friends. I dig it.