After a long night, we were super excited to learn that this place is open until 3 on weekends - Village Pizza in Shadyside used to be my standby for those hours, but that place gets so unbelievably hectic and cramped at night.
There was a great selection of several pies ready to go. I had the white with tomato and spinach and it was transcendantly garlicky. Slices are big and "pricey" for Pittsburgh, maybe, at $3.75-$4.25, but you will probably be satisfied by one, or two if you're starving.