Bought a Groupon (for four) and there was an additional 20% off that day on Groupon so I paid only 42$ for one lobster, one piece of corn per person, one garlic bread per person and two bags of a pound each (shrimp and mussels).
Service was great and friendly.
Now the food does not deserve more than 3 stars. The lobster was tiny, I doubt it was even one pound. The sauce was okay (mix of all sauces, medium) but nothing like the sauce you would find at boiling crab in Los Angeles, which is where I discovered that type of food. It was a little bit bland.
I would suggest going to the Boil Bar only if you have a Groupon.