I would agree with the other reviewers who rank Burgatory above Brgr in Shadyside. Last time I was here, I had an Elk burger with a blueberry Stilton, and it was absolutely amazing. Add a decent beer selection & the best onion rings I've ever had, and I'm sold. It can be crowded, especially on weekends, but I've never had a hard time finding a seat at the bar.
Probably the only reason to ever visit Waterworks Mall.