I can recommend everything we got on our first visit:
Beer:
Excellent selection of german-centric beers. We had the Hofbrau Dark, and the Aventinus. Both delicious. The Aventinus was almost twice as much, so next time, I'll just get two Hofbraus.
Food:
It's German Comfort Food - like Melt, but 'Schmelze.' I had the Potato Pancake Reuben. Kind of like the Grilled-Cheese-Cheese-Burger at the Beer Engine; true guilty pleasure that's worth it once a year. The Chicken Paprikash was also very good.
I wish I had found this place sooner!