Overall: 4 stars. The food and interior are excellent. Service is very good, and prices are on the high side.
Service: 4 stars. The server was attentive and knowledgeable, but a bit hard to find sometimes. Free valet is nice, although the parking lot was a mess to drive through. They had a singer with a guitar, who was good but very loud and made it hard to have a conversation.
Food: 5 stars. The appetizer tuna nachos were excellent. For the entree, I got the chicken madeira, which was very good too, I also like how they have their own beers. For the Manhattan drink, they put in way too much ice; it shouldn't be served that cold.
Prices: 3 stars. The prices were on the high side, but expected for a nicer restaurant.
Interior Appearance: 5 stars. I like the classic feel of a lodge. The wood burning fireplace in a restaurant is something I haven't seen in a long time.