This review is not for this store, but rather my experience in buying shoes via their catalogue.
I have been a fan of J&M dress shoes for decades and I decided last year to try out their blue suede Allister casual shoes. While they look great, these have turned out to be far below J&M standards when it comes to quality.
I wear them once or twice per month to the office, and I notice that the rubber soles are nearly worn out. Since they are part of dozens of pairs of shoes which I rotate, there should be no reason for them to wear out that quickly if they were better constructed.
I did reach out to J&M customer service, and received a condescending reply suggesting I wear them too frequently. Poorly played.
For they money, I am sticking with Allen Edmonds going forward. Better quality and they stand behind their products.