The food was good. There was plenty of burger choices, but not much else in the way of variety. That earns four stars.
Subtract one star because they do not split checks, although we were advised if we had sat at the bar, the checks could be individualized.
The server was certainly not on top of her game. Subtract another star. Getting things was like pulling teeth. When ice tea was delivered, one guest asked for a straw. Instead of bringing back additional straws for the table, she brought one. Another guest asked for silverware since none is provided to start with. Same thing. She brought one set. Catching on to her skill set, the next time she appeared each guest in our party asked for silverware individually.
We have had excellent meal experiences while in Madison. Unfortunately, this was not one of them.