My mother and I have been here most Saturdays for the past five years.
I've had everything on the menu, under most every circumstance. It's not always "blow your mind", but it's a consistent value. You get a very good "bang for your buck" here.
The soups (when available) are uniformly fantastic. Their corned beef hash is the best breakfast item, and sometimes "sells out". The sweet potato fries are the best of that kind that I've had. Everything else is at the absolute worst, average.
What *really* sets The Goats apart is the service. It is the standard that I hold every restaurant to: even those with much heftier price tags. It's family-friendly, date-friendly, solo-friendly... environment-wise, the pinnacle.