I had higher hopes for this place.
I was drawn in by the theme and the reviews here. I must admit, the theme is pretty cool. I feel they could have pushed it further somehow, but I don't have any particular suggestions. I really enjoy the cut out book menus--I just wish they sat on the table with you so you could read them when you're through ordering!
We may have gone in on an off day, but the food was just ok. My boyfriend ordered the aztec chicken soup as a starter, which our server forgot and brought out after our meal got to the table. He reports that the soup was "ok." He also got The Tempest burger, which was good but fairly standard. The french fries that came with were bland. I forget the name of my sandwich, but it was a turkey club with a fried egg on top--good! I ordered the sweet potato fries on the side and they were served burnt. We both got sodas and they were weak--the syrup needed to be replaced in the fountain. We told our server, but instead of fixing the soda fountain she simply offered a different soda. (I'm pretty sure she was new to restaurant work. We were one of 3 table in the place on a Tuesday afternoon and everything seemed to take her forever to do.)
Since neither of us ordered an entree or drink, I may give it another try down the road. The service and food from my first visit left me unimpressed.