Yummy yummy pizza. Crust is mid range between thin and a thick crust. Tastes homemade. My favorites are their deluxe (what can I say, I like classics!) and the Ranch (bacon, chicken, red onions, tomato, ranch sauce). The latter is simply to die for. Their regular tomato sauce, which I think is what can make or break a pizza (in addition to the crust) is fantastic. I will say though, that people seem to LOVE the fetalicious but I think it's gross. Obviously a personal preference.
And this review is for pizza from all Glass Nickel Pizza locations (including Atwood Ave, University Ave, Fitchburg, and Green Bay). They are all very consistent.