I get it, they have a really cool concept and it's a great tourist-y spot, but I have never really enjoyed a meal there.
The inside of the church is beautiful but the ambience feels weird to me. They don't play music (at least not while I've been there) and it really throws me off because I feel like I can hear everyone and everyone can hear me because of the acoustics of the building. Also, I just think some background music is crucial while you're out to eat--it sets the mood!
The service here is decent but it almost feels like a chain restaurant rather than a funky, local brewery. Last time I was there my server didn't know much about the beers, which I thought was weird. They do have good pizzas and the beer selection is good but I think everything is over-priced (probably due to the tourist-y factor.)
I've taken people from out of town there twice, hoping to show them a good time at a fun local spot but was disappointed each time and wished I had gone somewhere else. It's not awful, but definitely doesn't live up to the hype in my opinion.