We've been to Sullivan's 5 times.
The first time was fantastic and full price.
The second time was Restaurant week.
The 3rd, 4th, and 5th was for their Sunday Prime Time special for various occasions.
First thing I have to say is AVOID RESTAURANT WEEK. They're way over crowded, the menu is limited, and you're going to wait.
Second thing... DEFINITELY hit their Sunday Prime Time Special. For $32, you get twice the selection as restaurant week, and the food is prepared fresh.
Third... get the Bananas Foster Bread Pudding for dessert. It's awesome.
Fourth... highly recommend Renee as a server. She was attentive, friendly, helpful, and on top of things.
So in conclusion... 5 stars for Renee, the Sunday Prime Time Special & the bread pudding.
2 stars for restaurant week (and take any reviews written during restaurant week with a grain of salt).