Have to agree with Alex D's review of 2/15 and give Amalfi's a "D" grade. The place is run down...dark, dingy and dismal inside, so don't expect an upscale restaurant experience here. The wait staff is comprised of young girls who are obviously not trained on the restaurant's menu or experienced at customer service. The food is OK but if you judge an Italian restaurant on it's marinara sauce, then Amalfi is below average at best...very bland and tasteless. We wondered if it was "dumbed down" to appeal to the Sun Lakers who keep this place open. We're in our sixties and were easily the youngest patrons in there last night. The owners who are supposed to "speak and cook Italian" were nowhere to be found.
This is a value proposition for retirees, as the prices are reasonable for the quality and quantity of food. If you're looking for really good Italian food in clean, upscale environment, try any one of Babbo's 8 locations around the valley. Closest is Rural and Ray on the Chandler/Tempe border.