Visited Cafe La Gaffe for Winterlicious with a group of 6 friends as it was nearby. The Winterlicious menu was pretty varied and had many different meat options.
I had ordered the smoked salmon salad, seafood pasta option and creme brulee. No dish was particularly bad - or good, nothing had really stood out or was particularly unique; although the salmon portion of the salad in particularly was very underwhelming. It was all very okay and slightly disappointing.
It's a quaint restaurant with home-y decor, the service was pretty good as the server was attentive to filling our glasses with water when we ran low. The lunch price for Winterlicious was $28 which I felt was a bit high for what was a very generic meal.
If you're in the area, it could be an option if none of the other numerous restaurants on Baldwin St. offer what you're after. However, it definitely would not be my first choice - maybe the regular menu is better?