This place is so close to getting 4 stars from me. I have been here for dinner twice, once with family and once with friends. Both times there was one or two meals out of the 6 that just fell flat.
With a group of my friends my girlfriend got the pork belly croque-monsieur pizza. There was hardly any pork, any cheese, and no béchamel sauce to speak of. womp-womp.
With my family my sister ordered a turkey flat bread. Now, I know that no one should expect food nirvana from a turkey flat bread, but this thing had like, one slice of turkey on it. womp-womp.
I have been lucky and loved the food I got (ribs both times lol). Also got a meat board and was very impressed with it.
They have some creative and good cocktails as well as a good beer list. If I can go to this place with a group of 5 or 6 people and have every dish come out up to par. Then the Oak Barrel will get 4 stars.