Sir Pizza is a perfect local pizza place. Prices are great, and the pizza is even better. The crust is thin, the pepperoni tastes fresh and is crumbled, and the sauce is delicious (worth ordering extra sauce!) Pepperoni and onion is a winning combination here. Pizzas are round, but cut into squares, which is kind of fun. The service is consistently quick and the staff is nice. If you eat in, the atmosphere is family friendly and feels just like a nostalgic local pizzeria. Side salads are pretty standard - mainly iceberg, but they're refreshing and fit with the atmosphere. They do have several beers on tap, including one from East End Brewing (usually Monkey Boy), and they recently started carrying growlers.
If you order during the week, the pizza is even tastier because they seem to put more toppings on.