The ice cream is good and the flavors are unique enough but there is nothing that blows me away. When you come and get just a plain scoop of ice cream, you are paying mostly for the convenience and the upkeep of a cool ice cream shop. The ice cream itself, I think, is comparable to that of a good ice cream at the grocery store.
That being said, the serving size here is pretty big compared to other stores around. You get a good amount and usually, I'm feeling pretty satisfied with my snack. To get more for your dollar, I suggest getting a pint and making your own cones with the free three cones you get with purchase.
If you are looking for ice cream that is much more unique in flavor, I'd suggest heading over to sweetie fry.