Not as cheap as everyone makes it out to be in the reviews (or at least, I guess, cheap for someone that lives in a 700k west island house) but the quality is definitely there. Everything in general is admittedly a bit more expensive while also unquestionably serving higher quality food.
Superior sandwiches, superior pizza and hands down the best deserts I ever had.
Honestly it IS worth the 5 stars. It's not dirt cheap, but for a specialty store I'd consider it cheaper than average.
The atmosphere and t he workers are a joy to talk to and the store, while being small, has plenty to give.