We went during Summerlicious, so it was fairly busy, but the staff was handling it really well. Example: we ordered 3 tricky martinis and had them within 2 minutes.
We weren't planning on getting the Summerlicious menu, but it looked great so we went for it.
The oysters were super fresh, the mussels were good and the people I was with really seemed to enjoy their desserts.
Beware, you can easily rack up a high bill here. Even with the prix fixe menus (+ 3 martinis and one bottle of house sparkling) we were at $240 before tip. Eak!
Will I be back? Hell yes! Oysters for everyone!... and next time I'm going to splurge and get one of those huge lobsters I saw the rich guy next to us eating.
Basically, I can't afford to be a regular but it was a great night.
PS: Beware the Summerlicious diners.. they are the worst.