We've been waiting to try Smoke for a while, and we're so glad we did. It was delicious!!!
If I could only pick one taco, I'd go for either of the breakfast tacos. I know, strange choice. But seriously. They are great. The chicken was good. I liked the veggie as well.
Also say yes to: the queso appetizer! the black beans! the Horchata!
The place is adorable. It has a cute little bar. There are very few tables so if you go during "prime" meal times, be prepared to wait. We went at 5pm on a weeknight, and it was perfect timing. Still... everything is cooked to order, and you can tell that the kitchen is small because everything that you order comes out very slowly... but it's worth the wait!
P.S. Bring some beer or wine and put it in their old skool fridge to enjoy with dinner because it's BYOB.
I would agree that it's not "real" Mexican food, but it's good. Just enjoy it and don't worry about classifying it.