I'd be rating the food at Postino Annex on here EXCEPT that I couldn't get any food there. Seems like if the web site says that the place is open until midnight on a Saturday, that one could actually get food in this gritty/urban/4 million+ people metro Phoenix area at midnight. But no. Kitchen closed at 11 pm, but the restaurant was still open for another hour. Well, that's helpful.
If you want to present a truly urban vibe, take a look at truly urban areas, where restaurants offer decent food (not Jimmy Johns) late in the evening, AFTER a show, for example. Might as well live in Payson, for crying out loud!
I gave the place one star because it's attractive.