My expectations going in were tempered because I know its hard to find great seafood in the city but my experience here was still a let down. The menu is NOT a real seafood menu as there were hardly any fresh fish options! Anyone with experience dining at real seafood restaurants will need to adjust their expectations.
In terms of fresh fish, I could only find one item on the menu so I ordered it. It was a cod which turned out to be a mediocre dish that didn't even fill me up...especially for nearly $30. I've also tried the scallops and I found them to be just ok as well. The oysters were a bit pricey and the same as anywhere else in the city. I've also tried the Fish n Chips for lunch and this was actually pretty good compared to my experience with the dinner options but it's less challenging to screw up something fried.
I do like the decor of the restaurant but I've been disappointed with the menu options and food quality a couple of times now so I can't really recommend this place. I'd give it 3 stars but have to give it 2 based on the prices they charge. Not worth it.