I love me some Il Pizzaiolo...
Everything about our date night here was pretty awesome. It was a Friday night, we had a reservation so we were promptly taken to our table, the service was great, and the food and wine were delicious.
We went with the Montepulciano D'Abruzzo... so good I tracked it down at a wine store in NY and will pick up a few (much more cost effective bottles) bottles when I am working in the Buffalo area. We had apps and salads and I do not recall exactly which ones, so I am sorry that I am at a loss here. I will say that my margherita pizza and my husband's gnocchi were two of the best things I have ever eaten. He loved the tiramisu too (a close second to Groceria Italiana's I believe).
There is nothing that I dislike about this place. I cannot wait to come back and this time, it is my turn to get the gnocchi (it was that good).
I recommend this spot for date night :)