Found this gem while browsing the Summerlicious menu. Not sure about their regular menu, but during Summerlicious you can get an amazing three course meal for a great price.
If you appreciate seafood as much as I do, especially oysters, you should definitely try Starfish. Even with the smaller Summerlicious menu it was hard to choose. We each tried a different dish and they were all very tasty and well-prepared.
The service was also very good, even when the restaurant was packed. We had lots of questions about the items on the menu and our waiter was very patient with us and definitely knew what he was talking about.
The decor isn't anything fancy, but is definitely cozy. The floor isn't quite level in some areas (even before the wine sets in), so watch your step! The seats at the bar were very popular that evening, but our group was better-suited for a table. We were seated in the back room, which was nice and private at first, but quickly filled up and got a little noisy.
If you're driving, watch out for the timing of street parking. Our dinner reservation was relatively early (around 6pm) and we had to wait for rush hour to end before being allowed to park there on a weeknight.
Can't wait for Summerlicious!