I go here just about every two weeks. I have a problem. This place is too close to my house. The staff pretty much knows me by name. It's almost embarrassing. But it is SERIOUSLY SO GOOD. THE BEST EVER, even. Ice cream is my favorite thing ever and this is my favorite place to get it. My favorite on their permanent menu is their Cardamom ice cream, and my close second would be the Strawberry. I also adore their Vanilla - it's just so rich! My favorite ice cream sandwich is the Salted Caramel. I find the Salted Caramel ice cream to be too rich on it's own, but it works perfectly in an ice cream sandwich format. Their best seasonal ice creams are the Cereal Milk Crunch (VILLAGE, IF YOU'RE LISTENING, PLEASE ADD THIS TO YOUR PERMANENT MENU!) and their Candy Cane ice cream (watch for this around Christmas!). There can be a line up sometimes, but it moves fast and is SO WORTH IT. It is not a deterrent in the slightest.
I love you, Village. Never leave me.