My wife stumbled upon Antney's on Yelp a few days ago (we were looking for some "must visit" spots in the Pittsburgh area during our stay.) We had a chance to try them this afternoon. I ordered a scoop of strawberry cheesecake and caramelized banana in a cup. Both flavors were tasty.... Much like hotdogs, its hard to screw up or excel with ice cream. Places can offer unique flavors, but it's still ice cream that another place can likely duplicate. Not taking away from the staff at Antney's. Everyone in my group enjoyed their ice cream and the staff there was super nice. Regarding a 5 star review though, i tend reserve those for places that blow me away with both product and service. Despite the 4 star rating I'm giving Antney's, i would still highly recommend it. Its always fun to try mom and pop places in a world dominated by large chains.