Go to Mike's, watch a game, order the Sante Fe burger (chorizo and beef) or Black Bean burger, order a craft beer, devour it, thank me later.
This is honestly, the best place to eat in Berea. I wish they would open the back room for regular diners instead of special events, but even the smaller dining room give a nice vibe. Expect to wait 20 minutes or so in the smallish waiting area by the front door, but you can strike up a conversation with other regulars.
Parking can sometimes be a pain, but look for a spot on the street in front or the smaller lot in the back.
Nice craft beer selection and very tasty food. Give it a try.