We have visited 3 times, trying something different each time we went. Mussels, Fried Calamari, Steam Pots and even the Crab Cheeseburger were all on point. They have a decent happy hour that put our bill into the $50 range for the two of us - 2 happy hour specials, (1) $15 entree and 2 happy hour beers.
The only reason I give them 4, instead of 5 stars is the price. $33 for a dozen oysters is high, Casey Moore's runs $14 (happy hour).
All in all I walk away happy, with a smile on my face after enjoying a delicious meal.