I hate tire shopping. Like most things car repair/maintenance related, it's pretty much an invitation to be violated.
But unfortunately, tires wear down, and we aren't at a place technologically where steel-belted radials can regenerate on their own.
A neighbor recommended Community Tire, and some research on Yelp confirmed their solid reputation in an industry that's otherwise inhabited by snakes.
Eric, the manager at Community Tire's University/40th Street location was really friendly on the phone. He quoted me a price I could live with and guaranteed me that they could turn the job around in an hour.
Not only did I pay *exactly* what Eric quoted me (no hidden rubber taxes), but not once did anyone at Community Tire try to upsell me on the tires or services. They checked my brakes and alignment for nothing, and had me back on the road in like 40 minutes. Pretty amazing service from start to finish and a refreshing alternative to the Big Name shops.
One more side note: Their lounge is really nice. Clean and comfortable with a flat screen and current magazines like Sports Illustrated and People, plus a popcorn machine, water dispenser, and coffee.