Vintage, you definitely fit into the "Ok" category. The drinks are ok, but not ok enough to offset my annoyance at how little seating there is.
The drink specials are great, especially the $1 bottles of Wisconsin beer on Mondays, but I think thats what raises it in my book from a 2 to a 3..
I would rather go to the Vintage than basically any other bar in a 2 block radius from there, but my feet are usually willing to take me to block 3.