To be honest the food is very bland. I have been here several times, and each time I felt I could have done myself a favor and cooked the dish myself.
Alice F does get bonus points for atmosphere. The service is above average, there is lots of room for groups, and as previously mentioned the patio is pretty nice. I think this would be a decent place to go for some appetizers and drinks (Sangria is great) and then head on to somewhere else. The theater crowd will find much better choices in the near vicinity.