I've been here multiple times for their ice cream and it's always worth it and I never regret it. Cash only. But I can't ever say no whenever someone suggests stopping by here.
However my review is for the ice cream cake! They just need two days notice and the cake is half cake and half ice cream. You can choose between yellow and chocolate and then whatever ice cream flavor you want! They two sizes: 8" and 10" round cakes. We got the 8" and that was plenty for the 6 of us; the cost was around $21 I think and the 10" isn't that much more, we just didn't get it because we wouldn't be able to finish it.
The cake was absolutely delicious! Not to mention gorgeous, the colors were beautiful. We did chocolate with chocolate chip ice cream. I would definitely recommend grabbing this cake for a celebration, Dave and Andy's does not disappoint!