My husband and I were visiting Madison for the first time and saw this place near our hotel so we decided to check it out.
The comedians were great, and the staff at the club was really nice and helpful. I would recommend getting your tickets online before the show. When you buy them ahead of time you get to go through the VIP line when you get there. They also seem to seat you closer to the stage when you're a VIP.
Just be sure to get there at least 30 minutes before the show or they release your tickets to people who show up at the door. There is a two drink minimum (you can include non-alcoholic drinks in that minimum), but we only paid $12 a piece for our tickets, which isn't a bad price at all for a great night out.