I struggle between giving 5Church 2 or 4 stars. 5Church has the potential to be a great restaurant; it has a great vibe, found in a charming location, and entrees riddled with flavor. But some days the kitchen struggles and outright fails to provide a quality and consistent experience. Furthermore, a good night might be derailed by a waitstaff that seems to disappear hours on end.
Will I go back? Probably.
Should you go? Probably.
...but you've been warned. You may receive a 4 star night or a 2 star one, it just depends on the whims of the kitchen and the waitstaff.