After living in the valley for over 10 years I finally made my way to Avondale recently while scoping out locations for my next Hawaiian Experience Spa. One day I stopped at NYPD pizza for lunch and it was so good I went back again when I was back in Avondale a few days later.
The service was quick and friendly and the menu had lots of options. My wife got a Strawberry Fields? salad because she is watching calories and she loved it. It really looked good. I tried the margarita pizza the first time and the bruschetta pizza the second time. Both where excellent.
There is a bar but it was lunch time and we were working so we just got water. :( Speaking of lunch, there is a lunch menu M-F which has pizza by the slice.
If we open a new day spa in Avondale or a new day spa in Goodyear (which is a block away) NYPD Pizza looks like it will become a regular stop for us. Give it a try.