It's not touristy when it's dark outside and you can't see the foreigners anymore!
I have a thing where I like to try Alfredo sauce dishes at different Italian places that I go to. I ordered the Chicken Alfredo here and it was absolutely divine. In fact, it was so good that Il Fornello is currently in my top three places to go eat Alfredo sauce dishes.
The Harborfront (or "Harbourfront" for the Queen's bitches) is a beautiful view right outside the restaurant.
Warning - this place is not cheap. But it's worth it. Made my second-to-last night in Toronto a memorable one.