I've been here a handful of times over the 10 years it has been open. My wife and I stopped there recently for a Friday happy hour visit. They have 50 cent wings and draft specials during happy hour.
As others have said the service leaves a lot to be desired. Our waitress was average at best. The wings we had were ok. Sauce selection was far from extensive. Fries were frozen and from a bag but were ok as well.
Nice beer selection, and I believe they are starting their own microbrew soon as well. Place is clean and somewhat large. Doors open to have a nice open feel except for the cigar shop a few stores down and people smoking stogies with the smoke coming in.
I am going to give the Bottleshop another try with either a chef special or sandwich. It's ok, but you won't go out of your way to stop here.