Very nice service doesn't make up for bad food at a ridiculous price. They advertise a $7 breakfast special well after they don't offer it anymore. I think they should stop advertising it if they don't have it. The sign was still up as we left almost an hour later. No matter, we decided to give it a whirl anyway. Our omelets were pretty good - five minutes before they were taken off the grill. They arrived overcooked and rubbery and the boiled potatoes they came with were mealy and tasteless. It was honestly not a great plate for $6, let alone $13. We really regretted not going up Roncey a bit to one of the many spots where they have better food at half the price.
This place could be very good - the waitress was very nice, the location is killer, and the place has a neat lounge vibe. It reminded me of an extremely cool tiki lounge I used to frequent in Milwaukee. Maybe if they dimmed the lights a little, played up the rat pack decor a little, and fixed the food it'd be great. But for a restaurant, especially a brunch spot, food quality and value for the price range are just too important to me to say Skylight was average.