I stayed there with my daughter for her orientation to U.W. Madison, and we stayed there again when visiting her recently. The location is ideal. The rooms are clean and spacious, the beds are comfortable, and the bathroom is beautiful. My favorite part was that there was actually a separate recycling bin, something I've never seen in a hotel room. Also, there was bottled water in the fridge, with no indication that it was for sale. I drank it and did not incur any extra charges.
My one complaint is about the shower. Although the bathroom is very modern and lovely, and the half-door on the shower is effective enough at keeping water out of the rest of the room, it makes it difficult to share a bathroom if you want any privacy from other occupants. My daughter and I would have liked for one of us to be able to do our hair while the other showered, but we don't usually hang out naked together, so it took longer to get ready in the mornings.