I had the shrimp tacos, which were fabulous. My mom had the chicken tacos, which were less flavorful than mine. (She also didn't like that she had to put her own lunch together. I thought it was fun and I like to control the condiments, so I was perfectly happy to assemble my tacos).
Very knowledgeable and friendly staff, nice beer list. I haven't eaten in Carefree, but my guess is that it's worth the short drive to head over here for lunch in the middle of a Carefree shopping day!