Embarrassing fact: I took the 3pm tour last weekend, and the 2pm tour this weekend. There were six people who signed the guestbook between my visits...
Muddy River is the oldest rum distillery in the state - owned by Caroline and Robbie Delaney. Caroline gave both of our tours (she gives the short tours) - I'll have to go back to hear Robbie's version of the long tour so I can know all there is to know about their rum. Now that I have shot glasses from my tour & tasting last week, I can go back FO' FREE and do just that!
My favorites were the Queen Charlotte's aged rum and the spiced rum - I now own a bottle of each. With current ABC laws, you're allowed one bottle from the distillery per year.