Two words: COOKIE DOUGH ... MY FAV.
I've been in Cleveland for almost 6 months now and I just had Mitchell's for the first time last week. What was I thinking? I don't know but I have been missing out on what may be the best cookie dough ice cream I've ever had. It is really really sweet though so one scoop is large enough. PS their scoops are fairly large, I wouldn't go for two without seeing what one is like.
They have a wide variety of classic and unique flavors, everyone is bound to find something they like. The girls working were very friendly, and helped us sample some flavors.
Store was clean which is a bonus. They also have some of the flavors by the gallon in the freezer and also ice cream cakes ready to be taken home! I will be back for more :D