I'd probably give it 3.5 stars if that was an option, but this place definitely deserved more than 3. It was a cute spot, the apps were good, they have good happy hour specials, our waitress was friendly, and the love jugs had a ton of toppings that made them delicious. The entrees were good, but nothing amazing. I ordered a filet special that was topped with a fried egg. I ordered my filet medium, but it was definitely a medium well. The asparagus with my steak was a little too lemony. While I enjoyed all of the toppings on my love jug, it was a little too thin and too much milky. I would definitely recommend Eighth & Hays for happy hour for drinks and apps.