So I did come back to give the pistachio flavour a try and thank goodness it was there!
Walked in on a Monday afternoon and the place was pretty empty but our server was nice and allowed us to sample several flavours.
I decided upon a 2 scoop cup for $5 with pistachio and bacio which both had great nutty flavours, were smooth, creamy and not overwhelmingly sweet. My cousin also got the pistachio and their mango which I tried and thought had a nice preserved mango flavour and light sweetness.
Overall, I'm glad I came back and hopefully I'll try the more traditional sounding flavours the next time I'm there!